Most relationship reviews are a status meeting with a spreadsheet attached. Everyone confirms the account is healthy, someone notes a slow payment, and the review closes with nothing changing about the exposure.
The failure is structural. A relationship review usually measures satisfaction when the decision at stake is financial. Satisfaction tells you whether the counterparty likes working with you. It does not tell you whether the next invoice gets paid, whether the concentration is survivable, or whether the terms still match the risk you are carrying.
Six questions close that gap. Every one is answerable from records a finance or credit team already holds, and every one produces a decision rather than a rating.
1. What does this relationship contribute to cash flow, and is that contribution growing or shrinking?
Start with the direction of travel, not the size. A large account that has lost a third of its volume over four quarters is a different risk than a smaller account compounding at the same rate, even though the larger number sits higher on every report.
Pull three years of contribution and read the slope. A flat line in a growing market means share is being lost somewhere. A rising line on falling margin means you are buying the growth.
2. What do we actually owe each other once offsets clear?
Gross exposure is the number that reaches the risk committee. Net exposure is the number that determines the loss. If you buy from the same counterparty you sell to, the true exposure is the difference, not the receivable.
Map the two directions before the review, not during it. Where the setoff position is undocumented, treat the gross figure as the risk and fix the documentation this quarter.
3. How does this counterparty pay, and what does the pattern predict about the next invoice?
Payment behavior is the most honest signal a counterparty gives you, because it is expensive to fake. Days beyond terms, the consistency of the lag, and whether the delay is spreading across invoices all carry more information than a statement of confidence from the account team.
Look for the change in pattern rather than the absolute number. A counterparty that has paid at forty five days for two years and now pays at sixty has told you something. One that has always paid at sixty has told you something different, and it is not the same risk.
4. How much of my business sits with them, and how much of theirs sits with me?
Concentration is relational and it runs both directions. A counterparty at fifteen percent of your receivables is a problem you carry. A counterparty where you are forty percent of their revenue is a problem they carry, and it becomes yours the moment they cannot replace you.
Both numbers change the negotiating position. The first tells you where to fix exposure limits. The second tells you where you have pricing power and where you have an obligation to keep them solvent.
5. What would it cost me to replace them, and what would it cost them to replace me?
Replacement cost is the real measure of dependence. Time to qualify a new supplier, cost to re certify, revenue at risk during transition, and the switching cost inside your own operation. If that total is small, the relationship is convenient. If it is large, the relationship is infrastructure and the risk review should treat it that way.
Run the same estimate from their side. The gap between the two numbers is the leverage, and it belongs in the review as a number rather than an impression.
6. What changed in the last ninety days that this review has not caught?
Relationship reviews are periodic. Risk is continuous. Between two reviews a counterparty can change ownership, lose a major customer, take a secured position from a lender, or replace its finance leadership.
This question is the one that requires outside signal, because none of those events appear in your own transaction history until they show up as a missed payment. Ownership changes, legal filings, payment behavior shifts and network exposure are available before the loss, and they are the reason a review should open with what moved rather than what held.
How to run the six
Score each question on three states: stable, watch, or action. Anything scored action gets an owner and a date before the meeting ends. Anything scored watch gets a trigger condition written down, so the next review does not re litigate the same judgment from memory.
The whole exercise takes about ninety minutes per counterparty when the data is already assembled, which is why the assembly step belongs in a report rather than in the meeting.
What changes when you run them
A satisfaction review produces a rating and a summary. These six produce a limit, a term, a documentation fix, a concentration decision and a monitoring trigger. Those are the outputs a credit committee can approve.
The larger shift is where the conversation happens. Instead of asking whether the relationship is healthy, the review asks what the relationship costs you if it breaks, and what you are doing about that before it does.
Internal Knowledge + External Insights = Competitive Intelligence. That is your Decision Intelligence Framework.

